Church, Leadership and Liminality 3

We’re continuing discussion of chapter 2 of Alan Roxburgh’s thought provoking book Missionary, Congregation, Leadership and Liminality, titled ‘Liminality: a model for engagement’.

So far Roxburgh has described what he calls liminality. He develops this saying that these extraordinary changes and challenges tend to be compressed into one point of tension – the church leader or pastor. He or she is the one who feels these pressures most acutely. ‘Recognised’ church leaders used to have huge kudos within Irish Christendom but now their roles are under question. What is a pastor for? What do they do? Are they ‘ministers of the word and sacrament’ (as in the Presbyterian Church in Ireland) or a visionary team leader or something else all together? Chaplain? Coach? Counsellor? Strategist? Marketeer? Professional? Theologian?

What should a theological college be training church leaders to do and to be? [I have more than a passing interest in this question!] Roxburgh’s point here is that all this casting about for role and credibility is reflective of a desire to recover role and identity rather than embrace liminality.

Rather, he argues, we need to see liminality as a place of opportunity and transformation. The future will NOT be a place for:

  • Technicians:- experts in the latest 200 sure fire methods of “making your congregation the most alive, fastest-growing, seeker-sensitive, liturgical, charismatic church”.
  • Those wanting to be important and powerful:- Christendom bred a culture of power, respect and prestige around church leaders. While much of this persists, church leaders in post-Christendom Ireland face a very different context after Ferns, Ryan and Murphy Reports into abuse within the Catholic Church. Respect, trust and a right to be heard has to be earned not assumed. This ain’t a bad thing. Biblical leadership has never been about power, selfish ambition or pride – a truth that desperately needs to be heard afresh in Ireland.

OK these are a couple of negatives – I’ll follow up with some of Roxburgh’s positive suggestions in the next post in this series. But before I do, what do you think are the sort of leaders the church needs in post-Christendom Ireland?


4 thoughts on “Church, Leadership and Liminality 3

  1. The Church always needs Biblical leaders Patrick.

    Chris Wrights illumination of Moses’ and Jesus’ leadership at the weekend really said it all. Humility with GOD GIVEN Authority. NOT power thirsty and hierarchical.

    Interestingly though, Chris made a comment that the business world seemed to be moving toward a ‘softer’ leadership model – less hierarchical, quicker than the Church.

    ALL truth is God’s truth, no matter who finds it I suppose, eh?


  2. hi patrick I am with Norm on this one,”humility with God Given authority) as for your one who cant find his trousers, they will be where he left them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s