“Nothing fair, moral or just about what is probably going to happen”

Matt Cooper in The Sunday Times [Irish edition] on Oct 31 talking about the upcoming budget [no point linking to it, you have to pay to view! I did the old fashioned thing and read the hard copy.]

– the inevitability of further severe financial pain ahead;

– the markets’ scepticism over the Government’s rescue plans;

– the gaping chasm in the national finances that show no signs of narrowing;

– very real likelihood of a sovereign default and the International Monetary Fund being called in to run the country with mass redundancies in the public sector to follow due to the state’s inability to pay the wage bill.

There is nothing fair, moral or just about what is probably going to happen. Our difficulties have not been caused by the ordinary people of this country, be they public or private sector workers, the unemployed, the elderly or children. It results from the reckless actions of greedy bankers, incompetent regulators and an inept government.

This was compounded by the disastrous error in guaranteeng the libabilities of Anglo-Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide, two rogue operators. The exchequer deficit would be manageable were it not for the added €50 billion plus cost of the deeply flawed banking rescue. It is the so-called elite who have wrecked this country. But we’re stuck with it.

Cooper gets it. He captures the reason why Irish people are not revolting on the streets like the French. Yes there is massive anger at politicians and bankers, but deep down we know that ‘we’re stuck with it’. There is no alternative but to try to balance the books and climb out of the economic basket-case that we’ve become. We need Europe, we can’t go it alone, and we’ve shown we can’t be trusted to try. De Valera’s dream of economic sovereignty has long since disappeared (and even then it was an illusion).

What casts further gloom is that few believe there is the political leadership, vision, guts and imagination to re-structure the cronyism, clientism and waste in the heart of the political system that led’ Ireland into the ‘wilderness years’ that lie ahead.

Two comments:

Did ordinary people have no role in the mess we’re in? If people have unsustainable debt, what responsibility do they have for freely taking it on?

And if fairness, morality and justice are, in effect, being binned as irrelevant in the desperate attempts at economic survival of the state, what are the implications of such a move?

3 thoughts on ““Nothing fair, moral or just about what is probably going to happen”

  1. Patrick – re the two comments.
    Comment 1 – There is no freedom for all of us as the Government is making all of the decisions. The ordinary people (including me) sat on their hands as the Government sleep walked the Country into the nightmare we now find ourselves in. Those who did voice concern were quickly told to shut up or as Bertie infamously said “they should go commit suicide”.
    Comment 2 – A people going downhill fast !

    God and the nature of God has been fully sidelined from most people’s lives particularily the lives of our “Leaders”.

  2. thanks Paul. After riots by students today I should revise the original post! Yes, there was a myth that the markets (human creations) has lives of their own and could be divorced from ethics and values. And what makes me sceptical of the rescue plans is that they also seem to be divorced from fairness, justice and morality – and may well not work to boot.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s