Apostasy (5) Concluding Thoughts

I’ve been posting through some chapters of Phil Zuckerman’s book on Apostasy, Faith No More: why people leave religion and am fast forwarding to the end.

Zuckerman’s book is a good read. But after a while a curious reversibility becomes more and more apparent. Just as the journey to apostasy is (usually) gradual, so is conversion.

It strikes me that it would be perfectly possible to write a mirror image of this book based on 87 stories of conversion to ‘religion’ (a fairly useless word to describe something to leave or convert to but let’s stick with it). Indeed it could be argued that all conversions are a form of apostasy from something. In other words, apostasy can go the other way; from irreligion to ‘religion’.

Zuckerman argues that apostasy represents a refusal to conform and ‘is thus strong evidence of the undeniable significance and importance of individuality, variability, and human agency.’ (170). But the same thing could be said of conversion to faith, especially in the increasingly secular, post-Christendom culture of the West.

Throughout the book it is implicit where the author’s sympathies lie. This is made explicit in his self-confessedly impressionistic description of apostate characteristics: ‘courageous’, ‘bright’, ‘inquisitive’, ‘freethinkers’, ‘life-lovers’ and so on. Yet, the same words could be used if I was to compile a similarly impressionistic description of committed Christians I know (leaving out the fearful, slow, uncurious, conforming and life-hating ones I know 🙂 )

So while this is a well written and engaging read that sheds light on the stories, emotions, thoughts, experiences and struggles of men and women in the United States who have left faith and religious involvement for a more secular life, I am not sure that it tells us anything definitive or new.

Comments, as ever, welcome

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Apostasy (5) Concluding Thoughts

  1. Hi Patrick

    Your comments actually is right, I believe my own conversion was gradual. And I believe many people would agree with me so is theirs if they just recall how the LORD worked in their lives to prepare them to believe.

    So i am actually quite interested to read ‘Faith No More’, party out of curiosity, partly to see how to help those who are in danger of falling away (self included) lest secular life is just too attractive and Christian walk is just to ‘impossible’.

    Thanks!
    Selina

  2. Welcome Selina. It is an interesting book and he tells people’s stories well. Freedom is a theme that crops up – freedom from ‘religion’. And a lot of the time what is described is something I would want to be free from too (conformity, legalism, fear). The paradox is that authentic Christian faith is freedom, liberation, joy and forgiveness … Galatians 5:1

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s