A vote for Trump is reckless irresponsibility

If the Brexit vote in the UK taught us anything, it is that (very) surprising things can and do happen at election time. Sure it was going to be a close-run thing but the overwhelming consensus was that a Remain vote would fairly comfortably win the day. What was missed was the momentum was with Leave and the rest is (unfolding, messy and chaotic) history.

There are parallels – most have not seriously thought Trump could win, yet he has the momentum entering polling week. It is now more conceivable than ever that Donald J Trump could become the President of the United States of America.


Very thoughtful, non-American Christian commentators like John Stackhouse have argued that a vote for a third party in order to send a message to the main parties or to avoid contamination of voting for two awful candidates is basically a cop-out, ethically and politically.

He may be right. He also says this:

In this election, American friends of mine are supporting Donald Trump. They want above all to see the next president appoint a more conservative Supreme Court that will overturn Roe v. Wade and protect Christians from an encroaching political correctness especially on matters of sexuality and bioethics.

They are well aware of Mr. Trump’s manifest deficits and they know that they are taking the longest of political shots by trusting in a man who has (one wants to put this gently in a decidedly un-gentle campaign) no very strong record as a political conservative, a defender of the unborn, or as a keeper of promises.

Still, they reason, Mrs. Clinton will definitely be worse. And so they intend to vote for Mr. Trump. And I can respect that.

And Prof Stackhouse adds

Other American friends of mine are supporting Hillary Clinton. They want above all to see an experienced, moderate politician in the White House who will do some things they like and some things they don’t, but will not put much at risk that isn’t already at risk and likely will do some good in the process.

They are well aware of Mrs. Clinton’s deficits, manifest or otherwise, and they know that they are going to have to swallow some bitter pills.

Still, they reason, Mr. Trump will definitely be worse. And so they intend to vote for Mrs. Clinton. And I can respect that.

I am not as sanguine about respecting a vote by a Christian for Trump or Clinton within a sort of “equivalence of badness”. I can only see a vote for Trump by a Christian as being a form of reckless irresponsibility.

It is patently obvious that Trump is utterly unqualified to be President. He has none of the virtues required and all of the vices you do not want to see in a person representing one of the greatest experiments in liberal democracy in recent Western history, that has, with many faults, worked.

John Stackhouse is right to say that a Christian voting for Trump is taking ‘the longest of long shots’ that he might – just might –  show some integrity and values that could inform policy around political conservatism, defence of the unborn or keeping his election promises. There is little or no evidence Trump is going to do any of these things.

What we do know for sure is: he is a liar and bully; a man without any signs of integrity; who breaks promises; gropes women, admits it, then tries to intimidate and threaten to sue women who says he did; uses his power for selfish ends; who is running of a platform of ugly potentially violent nationalism; inchoate rage; not so incipient racism; and a ‘towering’ vanity that verges towards megalomania.

The idea that, whatever happens on Tuesday, that such a man could get within sight of the White House should be deeply deeply troubling to all who care about America.

I have huge affection for the country. Yes it has manifest flaws, deep inequalities, a history shaped by violence and an addiction to unsustainable ruthless capitalism (and Ryder Cup fans who lack civility). But show me a nation that does not have parallel problems, if on a smaller scale. I live in the Republic of Ireland and we are a tiny little place but do a pretty good job on political corruption, injustice, a history of violence, inequality and a neglect of the weakest and most vulnerable people in our society.

So this is not American bashing. It is an expression of horror that Christians, and especially well known Christian leaders, can come up with arguments defending the indefensible of voting for Trump.

Again and again in media reports we are told that ‘evangelicals’ are a key support group for Trump. I am not naive enough to believe that this is generally true. Those labelled ‘evangelical’ are likely very nominally connected to that label. Many evangelical Christians I know in the States are most definitely not voting for Trump – they are as appalled by him as others around the world.

But the fact remains that a lot of committed evangelical Christians are supporting Trump. I can only see this as a failure of discipleship – where a combination of loyalty to Republicanism and antipathy to the Democrats ‘trumps’ the bigger and more important moral duty to keep a man like Trump out of power.

And, such Christians may not realise it (but they should), their stance does nothing but harm the wider mission and reputation of the church outside America.

That evangelical Christians – who are called to follow a crucified Messiah and who are to be shaped by love for God, love for neighbour (where the neighbour is an enemy other than us), love for the foreigner, the weak and the vulnerable, who are to be people or peace and reconciliation – are labelled as supporters of a man of hate and division gives Christians a bad name globally.

The first duty of Christians in America is not to America .. it is to act in a way worthy of Jesus Christ and his gospel and for the good of the church catholic. And that means, I suggest, not voting for Donald Trump.

Comments, as ever, welcome.

6 thoughts on “A vote for Trump is reckless irresponsibility

  1. Kindly and respectfully, I voted for Donald Trump, and without remorse. I’d respectfully suggest you dismiss the sorrow, regret, suffering, and pain American-Evangelicals like myself feel with respect to the Holocaust of Roe v. Wade. It is not a mote point to many Evangelical Americans, and rather than be criticized, it’s time Evangelical Europeans prayerfully consider, Why? For me, it helps little when European-Evangelicals dismiss what is sickening, gross, and horrific to a God-fearing American like myself, and Why? is because I know my Sovereign Lord in the Kingdom of Heaven would NEVER endorse the ripping, tearing, burning, suffocating, decapitation of an infant’s head in the ‘name’ of a ‘mother’s right’. WHERE IS KING SOLOMON?

    America has been given an unearned reprieve as ‘life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness’ has been denied the unborn for decades. In national TV debate #3, the Democratic candidate supported killing, yes, even late-term babies. FACT.

    I am an avowed pro-life pastor and would never cast a vote for a grandmother who supports the legal-right to execute a late-term (or any term) baby. In the Bible, God sides with the widow, the orphan, the unprotected… America is nothing unless the little one in the womb is protected. Our late great President Reagan felt the same.

    Every Sunday I confess as a pastor “the sins of our [American] nation” which are great as are Ireland’s, as I also pray for whomever is President. However, I voted without regret and with a clear conscience. God used imperfect Nebuchadnezzar; God can use imperfect Donald Trump. Clearly the sovereignty of God raises up and disposes kings. What is absent here is not one expose’ on Ms. Clinton–corrupt to the core inviting criminal prosecution. As for the Clinton-Trump moral meter, in chess it’s called ‘stale-mate’.

    The herein article suggests that people like myself in America are ‘less than Christian’ for voting for Donald Trump. I find that regrettable especially when I hope my vote may somehow effect a Supreme Court nomination who will overturn the butchery of Roe v Wade.

    In America, those of us who are passionate about the unborn do so as a moral absolute–and at a cost, believe me. What is greater than the life of a baby? LBGT rights? Thriving economy? I hardly think so. I think Irish Evangelicals might want to consider, What are you doing to support the unborn? rather than muddling over how the vast majority Evangelical Americans voted for a pro-life Republican.

    Humbly and sincerely. Love undiminished.

    • Dear DWS,
      Thank you for modelling strong disagreement with charity and a commitment to relationship – much appreciated and reciprocated. If I overstepped the bounds of civility towards brothers and sisters who voted for Trump then I apologise. I hope I did not say such a person was less Christian. I can appreciate – and agree with – your passion for protecting the unborn. And that your choice to vote for Trump was driven primarily by that issue. I hope that Trump’s election does advance that cause – I guess we will have to wait and see.
      We’re going to have to agree to disagree on that choice – for me it it is primarily a question of character. Yes the moral failings of previous Presidents are legion and Hillary would have been no exception. But I lament that America has voted in a man who is a “demagogic populist” who seems to have no ideology apart from power and his holding it. I think in this he stands out as unique as someone who has actually got elected. He has made all sorts of un-keepable promises that he is already rowing back on. I hope I am wrong … but I guess I am not as optimistic as you are that he can do some good … and think he may do an awful lot of harm.

      • Thankfully there is One Messiah, One Lord, One Savior Who as we pray in our gathering, ‘Thy Kingdom come, Thy will be done on Earth as it is in Heaven.’ No politician matches up to His glory! And it is in communion with Him we find our common bond in the spirit of dialogue and the Spirit of peace. Amen. Your humble servant

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s